Is the "carbs" entry in Nutrition Facts net carbs or not?
My point is, the "carbs" entry actually seemed like it was intented for "net carbs" while the label doen't say a thing about that, making it look like an entry for total carbs, which is more than confusing.
I was creating a new food entry for my dietary fibre supplements. The label says it's 141kcal calories, 0g fat, 97g carbs (85g being dietary fibre), and 0.1g protein per 100g.
I input all the numbers as-is, including that of dietary fibre, and was told "the entered calories per serving does not match the amounts of fat, carbs and/or protein".
So this time, instead, I input "12"g into the "carbs" entry, and the application no longer had a problem with it. Seems like it's an entry for net carbs only even though it's labelled just "carbs".
Long story short, it is definitely confusing for users and it would be more than nice should it be changed to have a more appropriate label.
Comments: 4
Oldest
•
Newest
•
Most likes
•
Fewest likes
-
17 Jan, '23
Plamen Yankov MergedHighlighted comment
Show "Total Carbs" in the daily summary and food item values instead of "Carbs".
Currently showing "Carbs" and dietary fibre below it. It is not clear if fibre is also counted under "Carbs".
Having "Total Carbs" as naming convention will make it clear that it includes fibre as well. -
03 Sep, '21
Dave"97g carbs (85g being dietary fibre)"
That means you have:
Carbohydrates: 12g
Fibre: 85g
Fibre and Carbohydrates is not the same thing.
The confusion is with the label on your product, not Yazio.
Talk to the product owners who made the label. -
23 Jan, '23
Felix Kern System"Total Carbs Value" (suggested by Plamen Yankov on 2023-01-17), including upvotes (1) and comments (0), was merged into this suggestion.
-
10 Jan, '25
AskuWHEN discussing about carbs v.s. "total carbs" remember in the EUROPEAN nutrional labels the carbs DO NOT include fiber!
For example I just added a product with 24 g fibre, 15 g carbs, worked just as it should, well :).
But I'm having difficulty to understand the problem described above?
The math is following: 4 kcal/ g carbs -> if you calculate your kcal with 97 g carbs you end up with 4*97 = 388 kcal per 100gram of product so this is why you get the error if you put in 97 g carbs + 141 kcal because the math is all wrong. This is why you should never mix carbs with fibre..